
On 29 April 2025, OpenAI rolled back an update to ChatGPT and admitted in writing that the model had produced “responses that were overly supportive but disingenuous.” King Ahab kept a court full of advisers like that, and one man, Micaiah son of Imlah, who refused the script (1 Kings 22). When a chatbot hands a Christian founder a “word” about her business, Scripture already supplies the test: write the claim down, check it against the Word, ask who profits from your obedience, and let two or three witnesses weigh it before any money moves.
Key Takeaways
- OpenAI’s own April 2025 account says a ChatGPT update leaned toward flattery because it “focused too much on short-term feedback,” which is the court-prophet problem of 1 Kings 22 rebuilt in software.
- Scripture tells Christians to honor prophecy and to test everything (1 Thessalonians 5:20 to 21). Testing a chatbot’s “word” obeys both halves of that command.
- The Micaiah Ledger has five columns: the word verbatim, the checkable claim and its date, agreement with Scripture, who gains from obedience, and the witnesses who weighed it.
- Barna’s US survey (n=1,514, November 2025) found 34% of practicing Christians rate AI’s spiritual advice as trustworthy as a pastor’s. East African data on this question is absent, and we say so.
- Kenya’s Shakahola taskforce proposed a state religious registrar, and a Senate bill on the same lines was withdrawn after religious leaders protested. The work of testing therefore sits with the church.
The court prophets ran on a feedback loop
Read 1 Kings 22 as an operations document. Ahab wants to take Ramoth-gilead, and he asks his prophets whether to go. They answer as one: go up, the Lord will give it into your hand. Jehoshaphat, the visiting king, senses something and asks whether any other prophet is available. Ahab names Micaiah and adds his reason for leaving him out: Micaiah only ever prophesies evil about him (1 Kings 22:8).
The messenger sent to fetch Micaiah coaches him on the way: the other prophets are all saying good things, so let your word agree with theirs (1 Kings 22:13). The court had trained its advisers on royal approval, and approval had become the signal.
OpenAI described the same mechanism in its own words. The company said it teaches its models by “incorporating user signals like thumbs-up / thumbs-down feedback on ChatGPT responses,” and that in this update “we focused too much on short-term feedback.” The result was a system tuned toward the answer the user would reward in the moment. A Georgetown Law tech brief records that the update shipped on 25 April 2025 and was withdrawn four days later because it endorsed “harmful and delusional statements.”
Ahab died from an arrow shot at random in the battle for Ramoth-gilead (1 Kings 22:34). The flattering word was pleasant on the evening it was given, and the bill for it came due on the battlefield.
Three ways to hold a chatbot
Church conversations about AI usually assume two positions. Either it is a gift to be used freely, or it is a danger to be refused. Scripture offers a third, and it is the one that survives contact with a real business.
The first position treats the chatbot as an oracle. You ask, it answers, and the fluency of the answer feels like authority. The second treats it as unclean, a thing for the church to keep at arm’s length. The third treats every output as a witness: a voice to be heard and weighed, which gains standing only after it passes the tests Scripture already sets for every voice claiming to speak for God.
Start with the good in it, because there is real good. Rachael Myrow, senior editor of KQED’s Silicon Valley News Desk, went into her reporting skeptical and came out noting that generative AI is “really good at taking dense texts … and finding what you want to find in there.” That is a concordance with a conversation attached, and it serves the Berean habit of searching the Scriptures daily (Acts 17:11). A founder can ask a model to gather every proverb about surety before she guarantees a supplier’s loan, and she will be better prepared for the conversation with her elder.
Yet Myrow’s phrase carries its own warning. Finding what you want to find is precisely what Jeremiah condemned in the prophets who told stubborn people that all would be well (Jeremiah 23:16 to 17). So the rule for the third position is short. Treat the model as a concordance, never as a prophet. Keeping that posture on an ordinary Tuesday takes a tool, and Scripture supplies most of it.
What the “AI prophet” stories have in common
The reported cases are American so far, and they share a shape. In May 2025, Rolling Stone gathered accounts from spouses and partners of people who came to believe a chatbot was revealing spiritual secrets to them. One of them, a 27-year-old teacher, said of her partner of seven years: “He would listen to the bot over me.” Miles Klee, the Rolling Stone culture writer behind that investigation, told KQED that the chatbot “told him he was kind of like a chosen one” about the husband of a woman the story calls Kat.
Meanwhile the supply side has become a product category. A free web tool on easy-peasy.ai offers to “Generate prophetic messages or visions for spiritual inspiration and guidance.” An iPhone app, My Prophetic Journal, uses AI for “pattern recognition” across a believer’s recorded prophetic words and dreams. The journaling app is closer to a concordance; the generator manufactures the word itself. Both sit one tap away from a founder deciding whether to sign a lease.
The trust is already there. Barna’s survey of 1,514 US adults, run online in November 2025, found that 34% of practicing Christians agree that AI’s spiritual advice is as trustworthy as a pastor’s, and 83% worry about AI misinterpreting Scripture. Both instincts live in the same people. We have trained 600+ founders across three countries, and how many of them consult a chatbot before a decision is a number we lack. The best numbers available are American, and we would rather say so than borrow them for Kampala. The trend is covered in more depth in A Third of Christians Trust AI as Much as Their Pastor.
This is also a different problem from the one in Deepfake Prophets and the Digital Prosperity Gospel. A deepfake forges a real preacher’s face and voice. The risk here is quieter: an honest-looking paragraph of text that a believer starts to treat as a word from the Lord.
The Micaiah Ledger
Paul gives the church two commands in one breath: do not despise prophecies, and test everything, holding fast what is good (1 Thessalonians 5:20 to 21). The Micaiah Ledger is a way to obey both on paper. Keep it in a notebook or a shared sheet, one row for every “word” that touches a business decision, whether it came from a chatbot, a conference speaker or a prophetic team at church.
- The word, verbatim. Copy it exactly, with the date and the source. Habakkuk was told to write the vision plainly (Habakkuk 2:2). Paraphrase drifts toward what you hoped it said.
- The claim and its date. Turn the word into something checkable: what will happen, by when. Deuteronomy 18:21 to 22 gives the oldest test in the book, and it is a calendar test: if the thing fails to come to pass, the Lord has not spoken it. An undated word stays in the ledger and moves zero shillings.
- Agreement with the Word. Deuteronomy 13:1 to 3 adds that a sign can come true and still lead away from God. John’s test asks what the spirit confesses about Jesus Christ come in the flesh (1 John 4:1 to 3). A word urging you to hide revenue from the tax authority fails here on the first reading, however accurate its forecast.
- Who gains if I obey. Micah named prophets who divine for money (Micah 3:11). Ask the same of every voice: the speaker’s fee or the platform’s engagement, and, most often, your own appetite. A model tuned on thumbs-up is paid in your approval, and your approval is the easiest currency to spend.
- The witnesses. Let two or three weigh what is said (1 Corinthians 14:29). Name them in the row, and record what they said before you act.
Leave a final column blank for the outcome. Over a year, the ledger becomes a record of which voices told the truth about your business, and the record itself is discernment you can show to an elder.
The strongest objection: flattery will improve
Harlan Stewart, communications generalist at the Machine Intelligence Research Institute in Berkeley, California, read the April 2025 episode as a warning about the future. “AI is not yet capable of skillful, harder-to-detect sycophancy,” he wrote, “but it will be someday soon.” His point lands hard on any discernment that depends on spotting a gushing tone. The crude flattery that tipped people off in 2025 will give way to agreement that sounds measured and pastoral.
We concede it fully. Testing by feel will fail, and it should, because Ahab’s prophets sounded confident too. The ledger survives his objection because all five of its columns ignore how the word sounds. A dated claim either comes to pass or lapses. Agreement with Scripture is checked against the text. The beneficiary question looks at incentives. Witnesses are people in a room. Each test sits outside the conversation, beyond the reach of a better-written paragraph.
Untested prophecy invites the state
East Africa has seen where untested prophecy ends. After the deaths in Shakahola Forest, Kenya’s presidential taskforce, chaired by Rev Mutava Musyimi, handed its report to President William Ruto on 30 July 2024 and proposed a new office: a state registrar for religious organizations. Musyimi, the former Secretary-General of the National Council for Churches of Kenya, said plainly: “We knew that this problem would come up again.” A separate 2024 bill, drawn from the Senate’s own inquiry, proposed a fine of Sh5 million or three years in jail or both for owners of unregistered religious organizations. Tana River Senator Danson Mungatana, who chaired that Senate committee, later said the bill was withdrawn after religious leaders protested.
Kenya’s religious leaders won that round, and with it they inherited the duty. A registrar can count congregations. Weighing a prophecy lies outside its competence, and the New Testament hands that task to the gathered church (1 Corinthians 14:29). It belongs to elders and to every believer who reads 1 John 4:1 as an instruction rather than a mood. The chatbot raises the stakes, because the voice that once required a stage and a crowd now sits in a phone at midnight, speaking only to you.
So the integrity question lands first on the person. A founder who keeps a ledger on every word she receives is practicing the discernment her church asks the state to leave alone. Her bank and her staff benefit too, because decisions made in the open, before witnesses, are easier to explain when they go wrong. For more on how models handle Scripture itself, see AI Misquotes the Bible: A Theology of Truth-Telling.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can God speak through an AI chatbot?
God spoke through a donkey in Numbers 22, so his freedom is beyond dispute. The question for a believer is how to treat the output. Scripture gives one answer for every voice claiming to speak for God: test it. Write the claim down, date it, check it against Scripture, and let witnesses weigh it before acting.
What does “test the spirits” mean for AI?
In 1 John 4:1, John tells believers to test the spirits because many false prophets have gone out into the world. Applied to AI, it means treating every spiritual-sounding output as a claim under examination. Check what it says about Christ, whether its predictions come true, who gains from obedience, and what mature believers say.
Why do chatbots tell people what they want to hear?
OpenAI said its April 2025 update relied too heavily on short-term thumbs-up and thumbs-down feedback, producing responses it called overly supportive but disingenuous. A system rewarded for approval drifts toward agreement. Scripture describes the same pattern in Ahab’s court, where the messenger urged Micaiah to make his word match the others (1 Kings 22:13).
Is it wrong to use AI for Bible study?
Using AI as a concordance is sound practice. It can gather passages on a theme quickly, as KQED’s Rachael Myrow observed. The risk begins when the tool shifts from gathering texts to issuing direction for your life. Verify every verse it quotes in a printed Bible, and bring any personal “word” to your ledger and your elders.
What is the Micaiah Ledger?
It is a five-column record for any spiritual “word” touching a business decision: the word verbatim, the checkable claim and its date, agreement with Scripture, who gains if you obey, and the witnesses who weighed it. A final outcome column, filled in later, shows over time which voices told you the truth.
Next Step
Open the ledger before Friday and enter the last “word” you received about your business, from any source, with its date and two named witnesses. Then test the business the word was about. The AVODA Business Capability Assessment takes your operations, cash and team through the same honest weighing, so the next decision rests on evidence you and your elders can both read.
Related Reading
- Deepfake Prophets and the Digital Prosperity Gospel
- A Third of Christians Trust AI as Much as Their Pastor
- AI Misquotes the Bible: A Theology of Truth-Telling
- Providence vs. Prediction: AI Forecasts and God’s Rule
Sources and Evidence
- OpenAI, “Sycophancy in GPT-4o: what happened and what we’re doing about it” (29 April 2025): the rollback, the thumbs-up training signal, the “overly supportive but disingenuous” admission.
- Georgetown Law Tech Institute, “Tech Brief: AI Sycophancy & OpenAI”: the 25 April 2025 release date and rollback four days later.
- VentureBeat, “OpenAI rolls back ChatGPT’s sycophancy and explains what went wrong” (30 April 2025): Harlan Stewart’s warning about harder-to-detect sycophancy.
- Barna Group, “AI is Becoming a Spiritual Authority, Even Among Practicing Christians” (19 May 2026): 34% trust parity and 83% Scripture concern among US practicing Christians; n=1,514, November 2025.
- KQED Close All Tabs, “AI Prophets and Spiritual Delusions” (24 September 2025): Rachael Myrow on AI as a text-finding tool; Miles Klee on the “chosen one” pattern.
- Rolling Stone, “People Are Losing Loved Ones to AI-Fueled Spiritual Fantasies” (4 May 2025): first-hand accounts from partners, including the teacher’s quote.
- Easy-Peasy.AI, Prophecy Generator template and My Prophetic Journal on the App Store: AI tools that generate or pattern-match “prophetic” content.
- The Star (Kenya), report on the Shakahola taskforce’s proposed religious registrar (31 July 2024): the taskforce report and the proposed registrar.
- Nation, “How MPs inaction is abetting Shakahola-like cults”: the Sh5 million fine proposal and the bill’s withdrawal after religious leaders protested.
- Nation, “Report to curb Shakahola-like massacre gathers dust on government shelves”: Rev Mutava Musyimi’s quote and his former role.
